This season’s makeup applicator of choice? The crayon. Lipsticks are now lip crayons, eyebrow pencils are now eyebrow crayons, eyeshadow palettes are now eyeshadow crayons … you get the picture.

In this second part of my crayons choose my makeup series, I let random crayons decide my contour, eyeshadow, blush and bold lip shade. I start with a bright pink base and slowly blend in unexpected ...